XP Alternatives: Comparing Smaller, Ethical Discord Bots

As XP prepares to shut down in December, many Discord server administrators are on the lookout for suitable alternatives. In our quest to find the best replacements, we've focused on smaller bots that align with ethical practices in Discord bot development and operation. Our goal was to highlight alternatives that not only provide similar functionality to XP but also prioritize user privacy, fair practices, and community-driven development.

We compared three promising alternatives to XP:

1. Atom
2. Engauge
3. Iris XP

Each of these bots offers a unique approach to XP and leveling systems, with their own strengths and limitations. By choosing to focus on smaller bots, we aimed to showcase options that may be more responsive to community needs and potentially offer a more personalized experience for users.

Our Detailed Comparisons

For each bot, we've created an in-depth comparison with XP, including:

• A detailed feature comparison chart
• Pros and cons analysis
• Our personal conclusion
• Links to the bot's dashboard and top.gg page

You can find these detailed comparisons here:

• XP vs Atom: In-Depth Comparison
• XP vs Engauge: In-Depth Comparison
• XP vs Iris XP: In-Depth Comparison

Our Recommended Bot: Atom

After careful consideration and thorough testing, we believe that Atom stands out as the best alternative for XP users. Here's why we recommend Atom:

1. Feature Parity: Atom offers an excellent match to XP's feature set, ensuring a smooth transition for most servers. It covers all the essential XP functionalities and even adds some unique features. Recent updates have further improved this parity:

   • Atom now supports Auto Role, a feature many XP users rely on.
   • While not fully supported, there's a workaround available for Voice XP Cooldown.
   • Atom offers partial support for Dynamic Leaderboard, a premium feature in XP.

2. Seamless Data Migration: Atom now provides an import feature for XP data, allowing you to transfer your existing XP community levels effortlessly.

3. User-Friendly Interface: We found Atom's dashboard and commands to be intuitive and easy to use, which is crucial for both administrators and users.

4. Active Development: Atom's development team is highly active and responsive to user feedback. This is evident in their recent feature additions and improvements.

5. Cost-Effective: Many features that are premium in other bots (including XP) are available in Atom's free tier, making it an economical choice for budget-conscious servers.

6. Community Focus: With a growing user base, Atom offers a great opportunity for users to influence the bot's future development, potentially shaping it to better meet the community's needs.

7. Exceptional Community Engagement: What truly sets Atom apart is their team's dedication to the community. The developers are incredibly approachable, often interacting directly with users in their support server. They're quick to address concerns, implement suggested features, and provide personalized assistance.

While Atom still has some limitations, such as the absence of Reaction XP and Boosted Channels, we believe its overall package and rapid development offer the best experience for servers transitioning from XP.

Note: We are not affiliated with any of these bots. Our comparisons are based on available information and are intended for informational purposes only. Always conduct your own research before implementing any new bot in your Discord server.